10 Things to Know About the Status of Asymmetrical Wireless Backhaul

Paging through the radio spectrum

The ECC held a meeting in March to further consider updating regulations to allow the use of asymmetrical links in microwave backhaul (Photo credit: blese via flickr)

Last autumn we wrote about potential plans from a microwave competitor regarding using asymmetric band plans for point to point microwave communication links. To update this topic, we have put 10 things in parentheses that you should know about the current status of asymmetrical links in wireless backhaul. Last month at an Electronic Communications Committee  SE19 (Spectrum Engineering) meeting this microwave technology subject was discussed again. (1) The proposal under consideration has been reduced in scope and (2) the regulators present still wish to see more evidence regarding the need for change before agreeing to such significant amendments.

Asymmetric Band Plan Altered
A quick reminder of what was originally requested back in the autumn of 2011; a move from channel sizes of 7, 14, 28 and 56MHz to channel sizes of 7, 14, 21, 28, 35, 42, 49 and 56MHz in order to support different granularities of channel widths in all bands from L6GHz to 42GHz. However in March these proposals were altered to reflect channel sizes of 7, 14, 28 and 56MHz (i.e., no change to existing channel sizes) and asymmetric only in the 18GHz band and above.

The national regulatory authorities stated that even the (3) revised proposal cannot be accommodated with existing planning tools so they cannot imagine asymmetric links being deployed alongside existing links in their countries. A few stated that in block allocated spectrum the owner of the spectrum may be able to implement this channelization, but Aviat Networks believes that (4) the complexity of coordinating links even in block allocated spectrum should not be underestimated.

Saving Spectrum?
Traditionally, links are planned on an equal bandwidth basis, e.g., 28MHz + 28MHz, with a constant T/R spacing throughout the band in question. This new proposal would see links of 28MHz + 7MHz and furthermore makes the claim that spectrum would be saved. Numerically speaking this arrangement would save 21MHz for each pair, but (5) saved spectrum is only of value if it is reused. In many cases the “saved” spectrum would be orphaned due to difficulties coordinating it into usable pairs.

Asymmetric Channel Plan Limits Future
In our last blog on this topic we reflected on the fact that while there is some level of asymmetry today, (6) this trend may well be balanced in the near future by cloud services and other services that involve the user uploading content. We believe that (7) committing to an asymmetric channel plan now limits the future. (8) Symmetric channel planning allows networks to dynamically adjust to changing demands. A related concern is the fact that (9) spectrum once reallocated may not be easily clawed back to create symmetric pairs in the future. While some applications are experiencing asymmetry in traffic presently, we should not forget that some traffic patterns are still symmetric and where asymmetry is a feature, (10) the scale of this phenomenon may be overstated. Indeed, a major European operator present at the SE19 meeting voiced skepticism about the need for asymmetric support.

What do you think? Will mobile traffic remain or increasingly become asymmetric? Are asymmetric microwave links needed or can they be practically deployed in existing bands? Answer our poll below and tell us. Select all answers that apply.

Ian Marshall
Regulatory Manager
Aviat Networks

[polldaddy poll=6067567]

Markets

Aviat is pioneering wireless solutions across diverse industries, driven by customer challenges. Explore Now
$
Mobile Operators
$
WISPs
$
Public Safety
$
Government
$
Utilities
$
Oil & Gas
$
Mining
$
Transportation

Products

Aviat's products offer unique, tailored solutions, ensuring optimal performance and cost-effective network design. Explore Now
$
All-Outdoor Radio
$
Microwave Indoor Units
$
Microwave Routers
$
Split-Mount Radio
$
All-Indoor Radio
$
Microwave Trunking
$

Virtual Fiber PTP/PMP 

$
Private LTE
$
Network Management

Hosted Softare

Aviat's hosted software streamlines network management, ensuring efficient, accessible, and reliable solutions. Explore Now
$
Aviat Design
$
AviatCloud
$
Frequency Assurance Software
$
Health Assurance Software

Services

Aviat offers tailored services optimizing wireless infrastructure, from project management to continuous support Explore Now
$
Project Services
$
Managed Services
$
Support

Explore Company

Aviat Networks delivers reliable wireless transport solutions, backed by 70 years of expertise and a strong focus on customer satisfaction. Explore Now
$
About Aviat
$
Compliance
$
Responsible Sourcings
$
Leadership
$
Careers

Resources

Aviat's Resource Center offers a comprehensive collection of insights and tools to support your wireless transport needs Explore Now
$
Blog
$
Webinars
$
Collateral

Investors

Aviat Networks, Inc. is the leading expert in wireless transport solutions and works to provide dependable products, services and support to its customers. Explore Now
$
Overview
$
Press Releases
$
Events & Presentations
$
Financial Information
$
Stock Information
$
Investor Resources

Contact Aviat

Contact Aviat for network solutions, sales, support, and global locations. Explore Now
$
Discuss My Network
$
Schedule a Demo
$
Request a Quote
$
Request Customer Pin
$
Get Tech Support
$
Request an RMA
$
Upgrade / Buy License Key
$
Become Aviat Certified
$
Customer Training